[opensource-dev] Possibility to revert UI changes on snowstorm?

aklo at skyhighway.com aklo at skyhighway.com
Tue Sep 21 14:59:36 PDT 2010


Miss C,

as someone who's complained bitterly about the Viewer 2 UI, i wanna say
that i *like* change.  It just has to mean something.  It has to make
things better, not just different.  My opinion has been that the Viewer 2
UI seems to be trying to fix a lot of stuff that wasn't broken.  i think
what i'm criticizing is called "gratuitous change."

The added & improved functionality in Viewer 2 is awesome!  Everybody who
worked on that should feel real happy with themselves!  It's the using of
the functionality that's the problem.

It's not even stuff that skins are for.  Maybe people like shiny buttons,
or 3D ones, or whatever kinda color schemes.  Maybe even rearranged
toolbars & whatever.  The problem is pointless changes in the way a user
has to do the same things, things that were easy that are now more
complicated (or impossible!) without any perceivable reason for them being
that way, and drastic presentation changes that alter the way a person
feels about using the interface.

The UI isn't like looking in the closet in the morning to decide what to
wear, and matching earring & necklace selection to mood.  It's more like
where everything is in the kitchen, whether you can cook yourself an egg
sandwich for breakfast or have to eat some of McD's cardboard - or go
hungry until dinner, and whether you ride the bus or your bike to work. 
(Especially if it's raining!)

My biggest complaint has been that Viewer 2 UI's biggest change is making
SL less "real."  For me, that's the way wrong direction!  Instead of
browserfication of the controls and experience, i'd like to see things
moving more in the direction of controls and displays like enhanced
reality.  i think browserfication is going backwards.  i think others
agree?

Sorry if this msg was too long and sorta off-topic.  i'll go back to
lurking now.  Thx!

- AK

The point is people do not like change.  I love the new UI and to assist
people with making that change I have been working today on making the UI
look similar to the old one.  Such a coincidence this was brought up.  Its
going to be the same color scheme with a few shiny upgrades to make it
look more state of the art.  See link... 
http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4113/5012955294_3f0d0de19b_b.jpg

Miss



More information about the opensource-dev mailing list